Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie

Save this recipe on:

This Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie is the kind of dessert that makes people pause after the first bite. It’s rich, velvety, and full of nostalgic flavors that instantly transport me to a simpler time. I first had this pie at a roadside Amish bakery in Pennsylvania, and I’ve been obsessed with recreating it ever since. It’s no-bake, wonderfully creamy, and layered with the kind of flavor you don’t forget.

The real charm of this pie lies in its texture — the peanut butter filling is incredibly light and mousse-like, and it pairs perfectly with the buttery graham cracker crust and a generous shaving of chocolate on top. I love how easy it is to throw together with just a few ingredients, yet it always feels like a special treat when it hits the table. This is comfort food at its finest — old-fashioned, humble, and unforgettable.

---

Why You’ll Love This Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie

If you’re a peanut butter fan, this pie will become your new favorite indulgence. It’s ridiculously creamy, made with pantry-friendly ingredients, and doesn’t require turning on the oven. The graham cracker crust brings in a subtle crunch, while the chocolate shavings add just the right touch of elegance and contrast. Whether for a potluck, family dinner, or just a night-in treat, it’s a hit every single time.

---

What Kind of Peanut Butter Works Best?

Smooth and creamy peanut butter is the way to go for this recipe. I’ve found that using a commercial brand like Jif or Skippy delivers the best texture and consistency. Natural peanut butter, while tasty, can separate and make the filling too runny or grainy. Stick to the classic, sweetened varieties for the dreamy, cloud-like filling that defines this pie.

---

Options for Substitutions

• Crust: Swap the graham cracker crust for an Oreo cookie crust for an extra indulgent twist.
• Chocolate topping: Instead of chocolate shavings, try a drizzle of chocolate syrup or a dusting of cocoa powder.
• Cream cheese: If you’re dairy-free, use a plant-based cream cheese and coconut whipped topping.
• Peanut butter: Almond or cashew butter can be used, but they’ll change the flavor quite a bit. Still delicious, just different.

---

Ingredients for this Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie

• Graham cracker crumbs – This forms the classic, buttery base of the pie. It offers a slight crunch and balances the creamy filling.
• Unsalted butter – Melted and mixed with the graham crumbs, it helps hold the crust together and adds rich flavor.
• Cream cheese – Gives structure and tang to the filling. It blends beautifully with peanut butter and whipped topping for a light yet rich texture.
• Peanut butter – The star ingredient. Creamy peanut butter gives the pie its signature flavor and dreamy smoothness.
• Powdered sugar – Sweetens the filling while keeping it smooth and easy to whip.
• Whipped topping (like Cool Whip) – Adds fluffiness and lightness to the peanut butter mixture, giving it that mousse-like consistency.
• Chocolate shavings or curls – Adds texture, elegance, and a touch of bittersweet contrast to the creamy, sweet filling.

---

Step 1: Make the Graham Cracker Crust

In a medium bowl, mix the graham cracker crumbs with melted butter until the texture feels like damp sand. Press the mixture firmly into the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie dish. Chill the crust in the fridge for at least 30 minutes to set.

---

Step 2: Prepare the Peanut Butter Filling

In a large mixing bowl, beat the cream cheese until smooth and fluffy. Add in the peanut butter and powdered sugar, continuing to beat until everything is fully combined and creamy.

---

Step 3: Fold in the Whipped Topping

Gently fold the whipped topping into the peanut butter mixture using a spatula. This step is key for achieving that light, airy texture. Be careful not to overmix—just enough to combine everything smoothly.

---

Step 4: Assemble the Pie

Spoon the peanut butter filling into the chilled crust, smoothing the top with a spatula. Make sure it’s evenly spread all the way to the edges.

---

Step 5: Chill Until Set

Cover the pie and refrigerate it for at least 4 hours, or overnight if you have the time. This helps the filling firm up perfectly.

---

Step 6: Add Chocolate Shavings

Right before serving, sprinkle the top of the pie with chocolate shavings or curls. Use a vegetable peeler on a chocolate bar to create those beautiful curls.

---

Step 7: Serve and Enjoy

Slice with a warm, clean knife for smooth cuts. Serve chilled, and get ready for the compliments to roll in!

---

How Long to Prepare the Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie

Prep Time: Most of your time will go into mixing and assembling. It takes about 20–25 minutes to prepare the crust and filling from scratch. If you use a store-bought crust, that time can drop to under 15 minutes.

Chill Time: This is a no-bake pie, so the bulk of the waiting happens in the fridge. It needs at least 4 hours to firm up properly. Overnight is even better for a perfect slice.

---

Tips for Perfect Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie

• Let the cream cheese come to room temperature for easier mixing and a smooth filling.
• Don’t skip chilling the crust—it helps prevent sogginess.
• Use a rubber spatula to fold in the whipped topping gently to maintain fluffiness.
• Chill overnight for the cleanest, most stable slices.
• Use a sharp knife wiped clean between cuts for a picture-perfect presentation.

---

Watch Out for These Mistakes While Cooking

• Using natural peanut butter: It separates and makes the filling greasy.
• Overmixing the filling: This can deflate the whipped topping and ruin the airy texture.
• Skipping the chill time: The pie won’t hold its shape if it hasn’t set fully.
• Warm crust: Pouring the filling into a warm crust can cause it to melt and separate.
• Not measuring correctly: Too much powdered sugar or peanut butter can make the pie overly sweet or too dense.

---

What to Serve With Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie?

1. Hot Coffee

The bold bitterness balances the sweetness of the pie beautifully.

2. Cold Milk

A tall glass of milk is classic and complements the peanut butter filling perfectly.

3. Fresh Berries

A handful of raspberries or strawberries adds tartness and freshness.

4. Whipped Cream

A small dollop of extra whipped cream adds visual appeal and richness.

5. Vanilla Ice Cream

For a decadent dessert plate, pair a slice of pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

---

Storage Instructions

Refrigerator: Store any leftovers in an airtight container or tightly wrapped with plastic wrap. It will keep well in the fridge for 4–5 days.

Freezer: You can freeze this pie! Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and foil, then freeze for up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge before serving. The texture may be slightly softer, but still delicious.

---

Estimated Nutrition

Note: These values are approximate per slice (based on 8 servings):

• Calories: 420
• Protein: 7g
• Fat: 28g
• Saturated Fat: 12g
• Carbohydrates: 34g
• Sugar: 22g
• Fiber: 2g
• Sodium: 220mg
• Cholesterol: 40mg

---

Frequently Asked Questions

How long can this pie sit out?

It’s best kept chilled. Don’t leave it out for more than 1–2 hours, especially in warm weather.

Can I make this pie ahead of time?

Yes! It’s even better when made a day in advance. Just keep it chilled until ready to serve.

Is this pie gluten-free?

Only if you use gluten-free graham crackers for the crust. Always double-check ingredient labels.

Can I use homemade whipped cream instead of Cool Whip?

Absolutely. Just make sure it’s whipped to stiff peaks and fold it in gently.

What if I don’t have a hand mixer?

You can mix everything by hand, but it will take longer. A stand mixer or electric mixer is ideal for the smoothest filling.

---

Conclusion

Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Dream Pie is the kind of dessert that proves simplicity can be spectacular. With its creamy filling, crumbly crust, and that chocolatey finish, it strikes the perfect balance of texture and flavor. Whether you’re a lifelong peanut butter fan or just in the mood for a comforting no-bake pie, this recipe is bound to become a regular in your dessert rotation.

---

Print

Save this recipe on: