Classic Buttermilk Pie

Save this recipe on:

When I first tasted Classic Buttermilk Pie, I was instantly transported to a warm Southern kitchen filled with the smell of vanilla and nutmeg. It’s one of those timeless desserts that doesn’t need fancy toppings or complex techniques—just simple ingredients baked into creamy, golden perfection. The filling is silky and rich, gently sweet with a slight tang from the buttermilk, and it sits in a buttery, flaky crust that holds everything together like a dream.

I love how this pie feels like a culinary hug—comforting, humble, and nostalgic. It’s the kind of dessert that people always ask for seconds of, especially during holidays, family gatherings, or just a lazy weekend when you’re craving something special. If you’ve never made a buttermilk pie before, don’t worry. It’s one of the easiest pies to master, and once you do, it will surely earn a permanent spot in your baking rotation.

Why You’ll Love This Classic Buttermilk Pie

Classic Buttermilk Pie is effortlessly delicious. Its filling is made with pantry staples, and it takes less than 10 minutes to prepare. The tangy buttermilk balances the sweetness beautifully, while a hint of vanilla and a dash of nutmeg give it a cozy, almost custard-like quality. It bakes into a golden brown top with a creamy interior that’s impossible to resist.

It’s also incredibly versatile—you can serve it warm, chilled, or at room temperature, and it travels well for potlucks or holiday dinners. Plus, it’s an old-fashioned dessert that brings a bit of tradition and history to the table.

What Kind of Buttermilk Should I Use?

Whole buttermilk is the ideal choice for this pie, as it gives the richest texture and the most pronounced tang. If all you have is low-fat buttermilk, that will work too, though the filling may be slightly less creamy. If you don’t have any buttermilk on hand, you can create a quick substitute using milk and lemon juice or vinegar, but the flavor won’t be quite the same as the real deal.

Options for Substitutions

You can make a few simple swaps in this recipe without losing its charm:

• Crust: Use a store-bought pie crust to save time, or go fully homemade with your favorite buttery crust recipe.
• Sugar: Swap out granulated sugar for light brown sugar to add a hint of molasses.
• Flour: A bit of cornstarch can work in place of flour to help set the filling.
• Spices: If you’re not a fan of nutmeg, try cinnamon or leave it out entirely.
• Buttermilk: As mentioned, a DIY mix of milk and vinegar/lemon juice can substitute, but true buttermilk is best.

---

Ingredients for This Classic Buttermilk Pie

• Unsalted Butter – Gives the filling a rich and creamy texture with a slightly savory note to balance the sweetness.
• Granulated Sugar – Provides the perfect amount of sweetness and helps create that beautiful golden top.
• Large Eggs – These bind the filling together and contribute to the smooth, custard-like texture.
• All-Purpose Flour – A little goes a long way in thickening the filling without making it too firm.
• Buttermilk – The star ingredient, offering a tangy richness that defines the flavor of this pie.
• Vanilla Extract – Adds warmth and depth, rounding out the flavor profile beautifully.
• Salt – Enhances all the other flavors and balances the sweetness.
• Nutmeg (optional) – A pinch on top creates a classic aromatic finish.
• Pie Crust – Use a 9-inch unbaked pie shell, homemade or store-bought.

---

Step 1: Preheat the Oven

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C). This ensures the pie bakes evenly and develops that signature golden-brown top.

Step 2: Prepare the Pie Crust

If you’re using a store-bought pie crust, place it into a 9-inch pie plate and flute the edges. For homemade crust, roll out the dough, fit it into your dish, and chill it while you prep the filling.

Step 3: Cream the Butter and Sugar

In a large mixing bowl, beat the softened unsalted butter and granulated sugar together until the mixture is light and fluffy. This adds air and makes the texture smooth.

Step 4: Add the Eggs

Crack in the eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition. This step is key for a silky custard filling.

Step 5: Incorporate the Dry Ingredients

Add the all-purpose flour and salt to the bowl. Mix just until combined—don’t overmix.

Step 6: Pour in the Buttermilk and Flavorings

Slowly pour in the buttermilk while mixing on low speed. Then add vanilla extract. Stir until smooth. The batter will look pale and creamy.

Step 7: Assemble the Pie

Pour the filling into the prepared pie crust. Sprinkle a pinch of nutmeg on top for that traditional Southern touch, if desired.

Step 8: Bake the Pie

Place the pie on the center rack of your oven. Bake for 45 to 55 minutes, or until the center is just set and the top is golden brown. A slight jiggle in the center is normal.

Step 9: Cool Before Serving

Let the pie cool at room temperature for at least 1 hour. This helps the filling firm up for clean slices. For best results, refrigerate for another hour before slicing.

---

How Long to Prepare the Classic Buttermilk Pie

Prep Time

Preparing Classic Buttermilk Pie is refreshingly simple and fast. It takes about 10 to 15 minutes to mix up the filling and ready the crust. You don’t need any fancy equipment—just a bowl and a whisk or hand mixer.

Bake Time & Cooling

Once prepped, the pie needs 45 to 55 minutes in the oven. After baking, it should cool at room temperature for at least 1 hour to set properly. For best results, refrigerate it for another hour before slicing. In total, from start to first bite, plan for about 2 hours.

---

Tips for Perfect Classic Buttermilk Pie

• Use room temperature ingredients for a smoother batter.
• Don’t overmix the filling—just stir until everything is combined.
• To avoid a soggy bottom crust, place the pie on a preheated baking sheet.
• For a firmer texture, refrigerate the pie for at least 2 hours after baking.
• A light sprinkle of nutmeg or cinnamon before baking adds a beautiful flavor and aroma.

---

Watch Out for These Mistakes While Cooking

• Using cold butter: It won’t cream well with the sugar and will affect the texture.
• Overbaking: This can lead to a rubbery filling. Look for a slight jiggle in the center.
• Skipping the cooling time: Cutting too soon will result in a runny filling.
• Using low-fat substitutes: Stick to full-fat buttermilk and real butter for best results.
• Forgetting to shield the crust edges: They can over-brown. Use foil or a pie shield if needed.

---

What to Serve With Classic Buttermilk Pie?

1. Fresh Berries

The light tartness of strawberries, blueberries, or raspberries pairs beautifully with the rich pie.

2. Whipped Cream

A dollop of freshly whipped cream adds a cool, airy texture that complements the custard filling.

3. Vanilla Ice Cream

A scoop on the side enhances the pie’s warmth with cool contrast.

4. Sweet Tea or Coffee

This classic Southern beverage pairing balances the dessert’s richness.

5. Caramel Drizzle

Add a thin drizzle of caramel sauce on top for an extra indulgent twist.

---

Storage Instructions

Room Temperature

Once baked, you can leave the pie out at room temperature for up to 2 hours. After that, it should be refrigerated.

Refrigeration

Wrap the pie tightly with plastic wrap or store it in an airtight container in the fridge. It stays fresh for up to 4 days. The flavor even deepens after the first day.

Freezing

Classic Buttermilk Pie freezes well. Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and then foil, or use a freezer-safe container. Freeze for up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving.

---

Estimated Nutrition (per slice, based on 8 servings)

• Calories: 370
• Total Fat: 18g
• Saturated Fat: 10g
• Cholesterol: 110mg
• Sodium: 210mg
• Total Carbohydrates: 47g
• Fiber: 0g
• Sugars: 34g
• Protein: 5g

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between buttermilk pie and custard pie?

While both are similar in texture, buttermilk pie has a distinctive tang thanks to the buttermilk, while custard pie is usually more neutral or sweet in flavor.

Can I make this pie ahead of time?

Yes! In fact, it’s even better the next day. You can bake it a day ahead and store it in the fridge until ready to serve.

Can I use a graham cracker crust?

You can, but it will change the flavor and texture. Traditional pie crust provides better structure and contrast to the creamy filling.

Is buttermilk pie supposed to be jiggly?

Yes, a slight jiggle in the center is perfect. It will continue to set as it cools.

Can I reduce the sugar?

Yes, you can reduce the sugar by 1/4 cup without major changes to texture. Just know it will be less sweet.

---

Conclusion

Classic Buttermilk Pie is a Southern gem that proves simplicity can be stunning. With its rich, creamy filling and flaky crust, this pie offers a nostalgic bite of comfort and tradition. Whether you’re hosting a holiday meal or just want to treat yourself, this pie fits the bill every time. It’s easy to make, rich in flavor, and sure to be a crowd-pleaser.

---

Print

Save this recipe on: